Start Here
Uncommon Reality is a provisional systems-theory project. Read it as a structured argument under repair, not as a settled worldview.
The recommended path
Read cases by role
A case role tells you what comparison a case can perform. It is not a score, a proof label, or permission to promote a claim.
Failure illustrations
CS001, CS002, and CS003 expose bounded settings where a repair problem may exist. They do not establish the proposed causal mechanism.
Successful repair
CS004 tests institutional control and pressure reversal while keeping incomplete substrate recovery visible.
Boundary case
CS005 asks where slow physical or biogeochemical recovery should narrow an institutional-failure interpretation.
How to disagree productively
Challenge the scope
Name the population, domain, period, or outcome for which the wording is too broad.
Offer a rival
State what a competing explanation predicts differently, not merely that another factor matters.
Identify a weakener
Point to an observation that should lower confidence or force revision.
Expose a missing comparison
Failure, successful repair, and boundary cases must remain distinct.